A Case Study in Ethical Leadership
Balancing Employee Advocacy and Organizational Responsibility
A case study from my time as an Assistant Director: what a leader owes the people she supervises, what she owes the organization she helps lead, and what to do when those two duties pull in opposite directions.
As an Assistant Director, I supervised a team while also serving on the leadership team. I watched employees carry heavier workloads than colleagues who were paid at the same or higher levels, and I watched employees take on additional responsibilities without any path to promotion. I had a duty to advocate for those employees. I also had a duty to the organization and to the leadership decisions I was part of. This site examines that conflict and the choice I believe an ethical leader should make.
This experience challenged me to think about how I could remain true to my values as a leader while also carrying out my organizational responsibilities. It is a leadership issue that has stayed with me and continues to shape how I think about ethical leadership.
How to read this site
The Dilemma
The background, the two competing responsibilities, the ethical actor, and the stakeholders.
2Analysis
The available options, examined through several ethical frameworks, with the strengths, drawbacks, and stakeholder impact of each.
3Proposed Solution
The course of action I recommend, why it is the best option, and how to reduce its negative consequences.
4Reflection
What this dilemma means for my own approach to ethical leadership.
A note on privacy. The organization and the individuals involved are not named. Details have been generalized so that no employee or colleague can be identified.